APPLICATION OF CONFUCIANISM IN MODERN MANAGEMENT
OSRC *ORIENTAL
STRATEGY RESEARCH CENTER*
Introduction
Confucius (551-479 BC) was the founder of Confucianism. He
was an educationalist, politician and thinker. A core problem
for management is education. Confucius stressed human morality
and education. Therefore, the philosophy of Confucianism is
linked to management. This paper presents a Confucian
management model referred to as "The Humanistic Management Model
of Confucianism".
The modified model integrates five Western managerial
functions of planning, organizing and leading, staffing and
controlling with the Confucian approach, by placing the
Confucian concept of benevolence as a priority in corporate
mission as illustrated in the Table.
Confucian Humanistic Management
From the point-of-view of Western management, legality may
have priority followed by logic and human relationship, while
the Eastern concept gives human relationships a priority. Human
relations take precedence, and legislation follows in the order
of sequence by Chinese.
The Chinese emphasis on the human factor has become relevant,
as modern management has given increasing recognition to the
roles of human factors in management. The human factor has
significant roles, both in enhancing efficiency of production
through empowerment of the person as well as greater equity in
sharing the rewards of productivity.
For planning, the model emphasizes the integration of the
human factor with materials, manpower, money, machinery, market,
morality, management information system, and management.
Organizing emphasizes a team spirit of interdependence. Leading
focuses on morality and merits. Staffing emphasizes humanistic
management through education. Controlling stresses rules and
regulations as a combination and co-ordination of various
aspects of production. The ultimate aim is to achieve progress
but also stability within corporations. Thus, the corporation
produces profits by achieving acceptable results and
actualization of a corporate mission in the organization.
The administrative concept of Confucianism consists of
benevolence, the principle of 'Mean', harmony, sincerity,
loyalty, forgiveness, virtue, administration, and education.
Benevolence is a vital part of Confucius philosophy. From the
view of management, the importance of Confucianism lies on its
principles of benevolence. Benevolence is the core of philosophy
of Confucianism. From the point-of-view of management,
benevolence was seen to stress human relationship. Therefore,
benevolence is given as a priority in corporate mission.
In addition to benevolence, the concepts of faithfulness,
forgiveness, and filial piety are also the guidelines of
Confucian virtue. As regard the guidelines of behavior,
Confucius interpreted further the practical guidelines of
benevolence are gravity, generosity of soul, sincerity,
earnestness and kindness. Confucius states that according to the
'Mean', perfection is the virtue. The Confucian concept of
'Mean' is reflected by a moderate attitude of Chinese business.
The Chinese holds in business that one should be affable in
dealing with people.
Confucian 'Mean' for a Balanced Management
From the management point of view, "The Doctrine of Mean" by
Confucius, as mentioned above, can also be applied to the
following example. Pascale and Athos noted the difference of
Japanese and American management by using the concept of
Mckinsey's "7 S Qualities", which teaches that there are seven
major management qualities, viz. strategy, structure, system,
staff, skill, style and share value. They state that American
corporations emphasize the model of 3 S; namely strategy,
structure and system. They called it the hardware of management,
which has a heavy technical emphasis. The Japanese management
concerns the whole of the model of 7 S, that is, 3 S + 4 S. The
additional 4 S here refer to the staff, skill, style and share
value, which emphasise the social and human aspects. The latter
is called the software of management.
The last, "share value", has become pertinent in the modern
society. As the educational standard in the society increases,
people are becoming more aware of their rights and would seek
equitible distribution of the benefits of production. As such,
"share value" has become significant in affecting efficiency of
management and increase in productivity.
Some people in the management field put the software and the
hardware management in confronting positions. Some view the
hardware as more important than software management. From
analysis of the principle of 'Mean', the 3 S should be
integrated with the 4 S, the later complimenting the former and
vice versa. This represents the application of the concept of
'Mean', to integrate both the 3 S and 4 S, thereby producing a
more balanced management.